Heritage Insurance Services – Coldwater, Ohio
Auto/Car Insurance, Home Insurance, Business/Commercial Insurance, and Farm Insurance for Coldwater, Mercer County, and All of Ohio
Heritage Insurance Services offers a wide range of insurance products for your Personal, Commercial, Life and Health insurance needs. Our goal at Heritage Insurance is to provide you with a one-stop insurance shop for a high level of personalized customer service and competitive pricing. Let us be the only agency for all of your insurance needs…contact us today!
History
Mark ReigelspergerPresident
Mark Reigelsperger started in the insurance industry in 1988 as a commercial underwriter. In 2001, he founded Heritage Insurance Services beginning with his own auto and home policies. The agency is set up as a one-stop shop for all of your insurance needs. Since then, through hard work and the best staff in the insurance business, the agency has grown to be to well respected amongst peer agencies as one of the most knowledgeable and best customer service oriented agencies in western Ohio. The staff at Heritage Insurance believes in the Woody Hayes philosophy of “You win with people” and at Heritage Insurance you too will win with our knowledgeable and caring staff.
Over the years, other independent agents and agencies have decided to join the Heritage Insurance Services team. There is no greater compliment to our outstanding service, than to have these agents & agencies entrust us with the service of their former clients. Heritage Insurance is proud to service all the former clients of Joseph Marshall Insurance (Englewood & Tipp City, Ohio), David “Dave” Kearney Insurance (Dayton, Ohio) and Damian Dorsten Insurance (Bryan, Ohio).
Heritage Insurance Services offers products and services through some of the best insurance carriers in the market today. Along with Erie Insurance Group, we represent Celina Group, Donegal, Foremost, Grange, Hartford, Liberty Mutual, Pekin, Philadelphia, Progressive, Safeco, and Westbend-NSI as well as many other life & health and specialty auto carriers. Our goal at Heritage Insurance is to provide you with the best coverage for the best rate possible, and as always, the highest level of customer service.
In 2015, as a leading service oriented agency, we implemented a Customer Claims Coordinator position to assist customers throughout the claims process to ensure their understanding of the claims process and settlement. Let Heritage Insurance Services be the only agency for all of your insurance needs. Contact us today!
ERIEINSURANCE.COM NEWSFEED
When Water Damage Hit Her New Dental Office, ERIE Helped Her Get Back to Business
Posted: June 9, 2026
Dr. Yooson Kim has spent the last 20 years doing steady, careful work—helping people feel comfortable in the dentist’s chair and building a practice her patients trust. Like many business owners, she also knows that trust matters just as much behind the scenes: with vendors, employees and especially the insurance carrier she chose to help protect what she’s built. That’s why, after years with a...
Do You Need an Insurance Agent? 15 Signs It Might Be Time
Posted: June 4, 2026
Having a knowledgeable and responsive agent in your corner is critical to helping make sure your insurance keeps up with your unique life situations. They understand everyone has different insurance needs, which adds value to the human touch they offer. While buying insurance directly online can seem like a convenient way to obtain coverage, life’s realities can make the task more complex. Agents also understand...
